In three states, a med spa can no longer count on a new injector repaying training costs after leaving early. Connecticut voids required training repayment notes signed on or after October 1, 2026, New York's Trapped at Work Act bars them from December 19, 2026 (or February 13, 2027 on a second reading), and California's ban covers contracts signed on or after January 1, 2027. A sign-on bonus can still be recovered in California and New York, but only under strict conditions.
Where the rules changed and when they start
California, New York, Connecticut and Colorado have statutes on contract terms that charge an employee for leaving a job early, and the first three changed those rules in 2026. Each date below is when a rule starts to apply to new agreements.
- California bars most repayment terms, including training costs and quit fees, in contracts entered into on or after January 1, 2027, and a worker can sue for actual damages or $5,000, whichever is greater.
- New York's Trapped at Work Act bars required repayment notes from December 19, 2026, or from February 13, 2027 under a second reading of its amended effective date, with fines of $1,000 to $5,000 per violation.
- Connecticut has voided required repayment notes signed on or after October 1, 2026 at every employer, including notes that call the payment reimbursement for training. Before that date the ban reached only employers with 26 or more employees.
- Colorado limits recovery to the reasonable cost of training beyond normal on-the-job training, shrinking month by month over the two years after the training ends.
What a training clawback looks like at a med spa
Practices that train new injectors often pay for an outside neurotoxin and filler course and then supervise treatments until the injector can work a full schedule. A clawback tries to recover that spending if the injector leaves early. It can be a fixed training charge due on a departure within 12 or 24 months, a flat amount labeled liquidated damages, a charge for revenue the practice says it lost, repayment of the recruiting fee, or repayment of a sign-on or relocation bonus.
A federal case shows how large these charges can get. In September 2023 the National Labor Relations Board's Cincinnati regional office issued a complaint against Harper Holdings, LLC, which does business as Juvly Aesthetics, over training repayment, noncompete and no-solicitation provisions, and over demands that two former employees pay $60,000 and $50,000 in training costs. The board's settlement announcement describes a clause under which an employee who left within the first twelve months owed up to $75,000 for training, and a noncompete that barred aesthetic services within 20 miles for 24 months. In the settlement, approved January 29, 2024, the company agreed to rescind the provisions, stop demanding repayment, pay more than $25,000 to two employees and post a notice at all of its US facilities.
Federal pressure on these clauses has since eased, which is why the state statutes matter. The NLRB general counsel's October 2024 memo on stay-or-pay provisions was rescinded on February 14, 2025. A federal court in Texas set aside the Federal Trade Commission's 2024 noncompete rule in August 2024, and on September 5, 2025 the Commission voted 3 to 1 to drop its appeals. Outside these four states, whether a clawback holds up depends on your own state's law.
California: contracts signed on or after January 1, 2027
AB 692 (Chapter 703, Statutes of 2025), signed October 13, 2025, added section 16608 to the Business and Professions Code and section 926 to the Labor Code, starting January 1, 2026. AB 1697 (Chapter 889, Statutes of 2026), an urgency bill signed September 30, 2026, moved the start to contracts entered into on or after January 1, 2027, made the law inoperative for all of 2026 and added exceptions. A contract signed during 2026 falls outside section 16608, though California's older ban on noncompetes in section 16600 still applies to it.
From 2027, a new contract may not make a worker pay the employer, a training provider or a debt collector a debt when the job ends, start or resume collection of a debt at that point, or impose a penalty, fee or cost for leaving. The statute's own examples of a penalty, fee or cost include a replacement hire fee, a retraining fee, a quit fee, liquidated damages, lost goodwill and lost profit, and its definition of debt covers employment-related and education-related costs. In a med spa offer, that rules out repayment of injector training, a flat early-exit charge, a lost-revenue charge and passing the recruiting fee to the hire.
A worker or a worker representative can sue on behalf of the worker and similarly situated workers for actual damages or $5,000 per worker, whichever is greater, plus an injunction and reasonable attorney's fees and costs.
One exception covers tuition for a transferable credential, which the statute defines as a degree from an accredited third-party institution authorized to operate in California that is not required for the worker's current job and is useful beyond the current employer. The repayment agreement must be separate from the employment contract and must not make earning the degree a condition of employment. It must state the amount before the worker agrees, without exceeding the employer's cost, and prorate repayment with no acceleration on separation, and it cannot require repayment if the employer terminates the worker except for misconduct.
A neurotoxin and filler course ends in a certificate, not a degree, so its cost cannot be recovered this way. Paying for an RN injector's graduate nursing degree is different: the degree is not required for the RN's current job and is useful at other employers, so a prorated tuition agreement that meets every condition can stand.
Sign-on and retention bonuses in California
A discretionary or unearned payment that is not tied to job performance, such as a sign-on bonus, can still carry a repayment term if every condition below is met. That clawback returns the bonus, not the training spend. AB 1697 also removed the original requirement that the payment come at the outset of employment, so a retention bonus paid later can use the same exception.
Take a $6,000 sign-on bonus with a 24-month retention period that meets those conditions. An injector who resigns after 10 months has 14 months left, so the most the practice can recover is 14/24 of $6,000, or $3,500, with no interest. If the practice lets the injector go because bookings are slow, nothing is owed. If the injector chose to defer the bonus, the practice pays the $6,000 at month 24 only if the injector is still there.
- The repayment terms sit in an agreement separate from the employment contract.
- The worker is told of the right to consult an attorney and gets at least five business days to do so before signing.
- The retention period runs no more than two years from the payment, and repayment is prorated over the time left, with no interest.
- The worker may choose to receive the payment at the end of the retention period instead, with nothing to repay.
- Repayment is owed only if the worker chose to leave or was fired for misconduct, as the Unemployment Insurance Code defines it.
New York: the Trapped at Work Act
Chapter 643 of the Laws of 2025, signed December 19, 2025, added article 37 to the New York Labor Law. Chapter 16 of the Laws of 2026, signed February 13, 2026, narrowed it and replaced its immediate effective date with one year after it became law. The employment law firm Littler reads that as December 19, 2026, and the law firm Holland & Knight as February 13, 2027, so a practice hiring in New York this winter should plan for the earlier date.
From then, no employer may require an employee or prospective employee, as a condition of employment, to sign an employment promissory note: any instrument, agreement or contract provision that makes the employee pay the employer if the job ends before a stated period. Such a note is void, and the rest of the agreement stands. The Commissioner of Labor can fine an employer $1,000 to $5,000 per violation, with each affected employee counted separately. There is no private suit for damages, but an employee who wins against an employer's suit to enforce a void note can recover attorney's fees.
Two exceptions matter to a med spa. The first covers tuition, fees and required materials for a transferable credential, which New York defines more broadly than California: a degree, diploma, license, certificate, or documented evidence of skill proficiency or course completion that employers in the industry widely recognize as a qualification, or that demonstrably improves the employee's employability. Training on the employer's own systems and legally required safety training do not count. The conditions match California's: a separate agreement, a credential that is not a condition of employment, an amount stated in advance and capped at cost, prorated repayment with no acceleration, and nothing owed after a termination other than for misconduct.
The second lets an employer recover a financial bonus, relocation assistance or other non-educational incentive that is not tied to job performance, unless the employee was fired for a reason other than misconduct or the duties of the job were misrepresented.
An outside injector course that ends in a recognized certificate may fit New York's definition, but the exception fails when the practice requires the course for the job. A clause that makes a newly hired RN injector repay a required course is void. A separate, prorated agreement for a course the employee chooses to take is the arrangement the exception describes.
Connecticut: every employer since October 1, 2026
Public Act 26-12, signed May 11, 2026, rewrote section 31-51r of the Connecticut General Statutes. Connecticut has banned required employment promissory notes since 1985, but until this act the ban applied only to employers with 26 or more employees. From October 1, 2026 it covers every employer, so a med spa with five employees is now covered.
The definition reaches any agreement signed on or after October 1, 2026 that requires an employee to pay the employer for leaving before a stated period, including one that describes the payment as reimbursement for training already provided. A note required as a condition of employment is void, and the rest of the agreement survives. The exceptions cover repaying money the employer advanced, paying for property the employer sold or leased to the employee, sabbatical terms for educational staff and programs agreed with a union. The act lists no exception for tuition or bonuses and sets no fine.
Colorado: recovery that shrinks over two years
Colorado's noncompete statute, C.R.S. 8-2-113(3)(a), lets an employer recover the expense of educating and training a worker only when the training is distinct from normal, on-the-job training. Recovery is limited to the reasonable cost of the training, must decline in proportion to the months that have passed in the two years after the training ends, and cannot violate the federal Fair Labor Standards Act or Colorado's wage law. Since House Bill 24-1324 took effect on August 7, 2024, the attorney general can enforce the rule and recover three times any amount an employer collects or tries to collect in violation of it.
If a practice pays $3,000 for an outside course and the injector leaves 6 months after finishing it, the most the practice can recover is 18/24 of $3,000, or $2,250, and only if the course goes beyond normal on-the-job training.
What to change before the next offer
Pull every offer letter, employment agreement and training agreement the practice uses and mark each term that charges an employee for leaving. Then work through the list for each state where you hire.
- Take repayment for a required injector course out of new agreements: in Connecticut now, in New York before article 37 applies and in California for contracts signed from January 1, 2027. In Colorado, keep only a prorated charge for training beyond normal on-the-job training.
- Drop liquidated damages, lost-revenue charges, quit fees and recruiting fee repayment from California contracts signed from 2027 and from required notes in New York and Connecticut.
- Move a California sign-on bonus clawback into a separate agreement that meets all five conditions above. Limit a New York bonus clawback to a resignation or a firing for misconduct, and describe the job's duties accurately, since a misrepresented job voids it. Have a Connecticut employment lawyer review any bonus clawback, since that act lists no bonus exception.
- Put the cost of training you can no longer recover into the pay plan instead, such as a starting rate that steps up on a set date once the injector works a full schedule, so nothing is owed at exit.
- Review agreements already signed. California's rule reaches only contracts entered into on or after January 1, 2027, but New York's act has no grandfather clause, and Littler advises treating repayment agreements still in effect on December 19, 2026 as open to review.
- Have an employment lawyer in each state where you hire review the templates before the first offer of 2027.
How the rules change the train-or-hire decision
In California, New York and Connecticut, money spent on required injector training stays spent when the injector leaves, and in Colorado only part of it comes back. That changes the comparison with hiring an injector who already treats patients. Training costs the course, the supervised treatments and the months before a full schedule, with no clawback. An experienced hire costs a higher wage and a recruiting fee and starts booking patients sooner.
California's list of banned costs includes a replacement hire fee, so a contract signed in 2027 cannot pass a recruiting fee to a hire who leaves early, and the fee belongs in the practice's budget. ScrubOps recruits experienced local injectors, NPs and PAs for 25% of the hire's first-year base salary, with no placement fee if you do not hire and replacement terms set in the client agreement.
Sources
- AB 692, Chapter 703, Statutes of 2025: employment contracts and repayment of debts on separation, California Legislative Information, October 13, 2025
- AB 1697, Chapter 889, Statutes of 2026: operative date and exceptions for AB 692, California Legislative Information, September 30, 2026
- Business and Professions Code section 16608, California Legislative Information
- Assembly Bill A584C, the Trapped at Work Act (Chapter 643 of the Laws of 2025), New York State Senate, December 19, 2025
- Assembly Bill A9452, chapter amendment to the Trapped at Work Act (Chapter 16 of the Laws of 2026), New York State Senate, February 13, 2026
- New York Enacts Chapter Amendment to Trapped at Work Act, Clarifying Scope, Creating Targeted Exceptions, and Delaying Effective Date, Littler Mendelson (law firm analysis), February 17, 2026
- New York Amends Trapped at Work Act, Holland & Knight (law firm analysis), March 9, 2026
- Public Act No. 26-12, An Act Concerning Workforce Development and Working Conditions in the State (section 4), Connecticut General Assembly, May 11, 2026
- HB24-1324, Attorney General Restrictive Employment Agreements, Colorado General Assembly, May 31, 2024
- Region 9-Cincinnati Issues Complaint Alleging Unlawful Non-Compete and Training Repayment Agreement Provisions (TRAPs), National Labor Relations Board, September 7, 2023
- Region 9-Cincinnati Secures Settlement Requiring Juvly Aesthetics to Rescind Unlawful Non-Compete and Training Repayment Agreement Provisions (TRAPs) and Pay Over $25,000 to Employees, National Labor Relations Board, February 6, 2024
- GC 25-05, Rescission of Certain General Counsel Memoranda, National Labor Relations Board, Office of the General Counsel, February 14, 2025
- Federal Trade Commission Files to Accede to Vacatur of Non-Compete Clause Rule, Federal Trade Commission, September 5, 2025