An aesthetic practice has three kinds of outside recruiting help: a contingency recruiter, paid only if you hire one of its candidates; a staffing agency, which employs the worker and bills you by the hour; and a retained search firm, paid in installments whether or not anyone is hired. For a single local hire, divide the recruiter's fee by what the empty role costs you each week, and bring in the recruiter if it is likely to fill the role that many weeks sooner than your own job post.

Who employs the hire under each kind of help

The main difference between these options is who employs the hire on the first day. A contingency recruiter or a retained firm finds the person and the practice hires them, so from the first day the hire is your employee, on your payroll and on your Form I-9. A staffing agency works the other way: in most cases its workers are the agency's employees, and USCIS lists people who provide labor to you while employed by a contractor, such as a temporary agency, among the workers you do not complete a Form I-9 for.

  • A contingency recruiter is paid only if you hire one of its candidates, with the fee set as a percentage of the hire's first-year pay or as a flat amount. It fits a single provider, esthetician, coordinator or front-desk search.
  • A retained search firm is paid in installments as the search moves forward, whether or not you hire. It fits a leadership search where the practice commits to one firm, such as an operations director for several locations.
  • A staffing agency employs the worker and bills you an hourly rate above the worker's wage for temporary or per diem shifts. Moving that worker onto your own payroll can trigger a conversion fee, so read that clause before the first shift.
  • Your own job post costs ad spend and staff time, and every step from screening to the offer stays with the practice.

What a search costs at May 2025 pay levels

Posting the job yourself costs the least in cash. Indeed lets many jobs be posted for free, subject to its terms and quality standards. Sponsored jobs are billed for job seeker interactions such as clicks or started applications, with a charge on the first of the month or when spending reaches $500, whichever comes first. The larger cost is the hours someone at the practice spends screening applicants, checking licenses, scheduling interviews and following up with finalists.

A contingency fee scales with the pay of the role. ScrubOps charges 25% of first-year base salary for injectors, NPs, PAs, practice managers and other leaders, and 20% for estheticians, laser technicians, treatment coordinators and front-office staff, with no placement fee if you do not hire and payment and replacement terms set in the client agreement. At the May 2025 national medians from the Bureau of Labor Statistics, those rates come to the amounts below. Recompute them with the base pay in your own offer.

  • An RN injector paid $91,230, the median for registered nurses in ambulatory health care, which includes physicians' offices: 25% is $22,807.50.
  • An esthetician paid $24.81 an hour, the median for skincare specialists in offices of physicians, or $51,604.80 a year at 40 hours a week: 20% is $10,320.96.
  • A receptionist paid $19.00 an hour, the median for receptionists in health care and social assistance, or $39,520 a year full time: 20% is $7,904.
  • A practice manager paid $105,770, the median for medical and health services managers in offices of physicians: 25% is $26,442.50.

The break-even test for an empty injector chair

A recruiter earns its fee by filling the role sooner than you would on your own. To see how much sooner, divide the fee by what the vacancy costs each week.

Take an injector who, in a normal week, treats 400 units of neurotoxin at $15 a unit and five syringes of filler at $800. The clinic collects $10,000, spends $4,500 on product at $7 a unit and $340 a syringe, and pays the injector $2,200: a $1,700 weekly salary plus 5% of collected revenue. It keeps $3,300. While the chair is empty, the clinic collects none of the $10,000 but buys no product and pays no injector, so the vacancy costs the $3,300 it would have kept. These are round numbers chosen so the arithmetic is easy to check, not market prices.

The $1,700 weekly salary is $88,400 a year, so a 25% fee is $22,100, or 6.7 weeks of an empty chair. A recruiter who fills the chair seven or more weeks sooner than your own post covers its fee out of margin. One who saves three weeks does not.

Two adjustments move the answer. If your other injectors absorb half the demand while the chair is empty, the vacancy costs $1,650 a week and the fee equals 13.4 weeks. A new injector also needs time to build a full book of patients, but that ramp happens whichever way you find the person, so an earlier start moves the whole ramp forward: over the first year, each week gained adds about one normal week of margin.

For a front-desk role the fee is smaller, but the weekly cost of the vacancy is harder to see. It shows up as missed calls, slower lead follow-up, and providers or the owner covering check-in. Put a weekly figure on that time and the same division applies: at the $7,904 fee above, a vacancy that costs $800 a week breaks even at about 10 weeks.

Terms to settle before you sign a recruiting agreement

Two recruiters quoting the same percentage can send very different invoices, because the agreement decides what the percentage applies to and when it is owed. Get each of these terms in writing before the search starts.

  • Whether the percentage applies to base salary only or to total first-year pay, including commission, production bonus and any sign-on bonus. On the injector plan above, 25% of the $88,400 salary is $22,100, while 25% of the $114,400 the plan pays over 52 normal weeks is $28,600.
  • How an hourly wage becomes a first-year figure, such as the rate times 2,080 hours for a full-time hire, and how part-time and per diem hires count.
  • When the fee is earned and when it is due: at offer acceptance or on the start date, and how many days you have to pay.
  • What happens if the hire leaves or is let go in the first months: a replacement search, a refund or a credit, how long that protection lasts and what it requires of you, such as paying the fee on time.
  • How long after an introduction you owe a fee if you hire that candidate, including into a different role, part time or as a contractor.
  • How to flag a candidate who already applied to you or was referred by your staff, so that a recruiter's later submission of the same person does not create a fee.
  • Whether the search is exclusive, and what you owe if your own post, a staffing agency or a second recruiter produces the hire.

Questions to ask a recruiter before you sign

A recruiter can only present a role that is defined, so settle the pay plan, schedule, license requirement and interview times before the first call. Then ask these questions.

  • Which med spa roles have you filled in the past year, and in which cities?
  • Where will candidates come from: injectors already working at other practices, or people who answered an ad?
  • How do you check injectables experience and license status before I spend time in an interview?
  • How many candidates should I expect to meet, and by when?
  • What do you need from me each week, and how fast do you need interview feedback?
  • Do you recruit for other practices near mine, and do you approach your clients' staff for other searches?

When your own job post is enough

A recruiter adds the least where qualified applicants already come to you. If your last post for the role drew qualified local applicants within a few weeks, your pay is at or above the local market and someone at the practice has time to screen, keep posting.

Bring in a contingency recruiter when the person you need is already employed elsewhere, such as an injector with a full book at another practice who is not looking at job ads, when two rounds of posting have not produced a hire, or when the break-even weeks for the role are fewer than the weeks a search usually takes you.

Sources

  1. Occupational Outlook Handbook: Registered Nurses, U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, October 29, 2026
  2. Occupational Outlook Handbook: Skincare Specialists, U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, October 29, 2026
  3. Occupational Outlook Handbook: Receptionists, U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, October 29, 2026
  4. Occupational Outlook Handbook: Medical and Health Services Managers, U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, August 27, 2026
  5. Indeed Pricing | Job Posting Cost at Indeed, Indeed
  6. Exceptions (Form I-9), U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services
  7. Completing Section 2, Employer Review and Attestation, U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services
  8. Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission
  9. Enforcement Guidance: Application of EEO Laws to Contingent Workers Placed by Temporary Employment Agencies and Other Staffing Firms, U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, December 3, 1997
  10. How Do You Count the Number of Employees an Employer Has?, U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission
  11. 29 CFR 1604.2, Sex as a bona fide occupational qualification, Electronic Code of Federal Regulations
  12. Employment, California Civil Rights Department
  13. Nursys QuickConfirm and e-Notify, National Council of State Boards of Nursing
  14. Verify PA-C, National Commission on Certification of Physician Assistants
  15. Using Consumer Reports: What Employers Need to Know, Federal Trade Commission, October 2016
  16. Business and Professions Code section 16608, California Legislative Information
  17. AB 1697 (2026): operative date and exceptions for AB 692, California Legislative Information, September 30, 2026
  18. California Bans Stay-or-Pay Employment Clauses, Morgan Lewis (law firm analysis), November 7, 2025
  19. The Stay-or-Pay Reset: California Delays AB 692 and Expands Permissible Repayment Arrangements, Greenberg Traurig (law firm analysis), October 20, 2026